Alabama Supreme Court: legal-malpractice clock starts when the lawyer’s act or omission occurs

In short. On November 6, 2026, the Alabama Supreme Court held in Maynard Nexsen, PC v. Cadence Bank (SC-2025-0419) that the two-year limitations period for a claim under the Alabama Legal Services Liability Act, Ala. Code § 6-5-574(a), begins to run when “the act or omission or failure giving rise to the claim” occurs, not when the client later suffers damage. The court overruled conflicting authority. This is an informational summary, not legal advice.

Last reviewed:

What happened. On November 6, 2026, the Supreme Court of Alabama decided Maynard Nexsen, PC v. Cadence Bank, No. SC-2025-0419. The court addressed when the clock starts for a legal-malpractice claim under the Alabama Legal Services Liability Act (ALSLA).

The rule. Ala. Code § 6-5-574(a), as quoted in the opinion, requires a legal-service liability action to be brought "within two years after the act or omission or failure giving rise to the claim." The opinion notes that earlier Alabama cases were split. Some started the clock when the client first suffered damage (the "damage" rule). Others started it when the lawyer's act or omission occurred (the "occurrence" rule).

The court held that the two-year period "begins to run upon the occurrence of 'the act or omission or failure giving rise to the claim,'" and stated that "[a]uthority conflicting with this holding is overruled."

What the statute still provides. The court applied the statute's other parts, as quoted in the opinion:

  • Late discovery. If the claim was not discovered, and could not reasonably have been discovered, within the two years, the action may be brought within six months of discovery (or discovery of facts that would reasonably lead to it), whichever is earlier.
  • Outside limit. No action may be brought more than four years after the act, omission, or failure.
  • Fraud. Section 6-5-574(b) brings in Ala. Code § 6-2-3, under which a fraud claim does not accrue until the fraud is discovered. The court said the party relying on § 6-2-3 must show its claim falls within that savings provision.

How it applied here. The bank's claim arose from legal advice on a loan that closed in November 2020. The court found the bank learned of the problem within two years of the closing but sued more than two years after it. The court held the negligence-based claim and the fraud-based claim were both time-barred. It ordered judgment for the law firm.

A note on the concurrence. Justice Bryan, joined by Chief Justice Stewart, concurred only in the result. He wrote that neither party had asked the court to overrule any precedent and that the claim was barred even under the damage approach.

Who this affects

People and businesses in Alabama who think a lawyer's mistake harmed them. After this decision, the two years are measured from the lawyer's act, omission, or failure, even if the harm showed up later. The six-month discovery extension and the four-year outside limit still apply, as the statute states.

Effective date

This is a court decision, not a new statute. It was released November 6, 2026. The opinion does not say whether further proceedings, such as a rehearing application, are pending. Check the docket before relying on it.

Related pages

Compiled by the Lawyer Dude®® Team. This article is general information about a court decision. It is not legal advice and does not calculate any person's deadline. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Confirm the current official code and consult a lawyer licensed in Alabama. Nothing here states or implies that Joshua Wagner is licensed in Alabama. Attorney advertising.

Citations

  1. Maynard Nexsen, PC v. Cadence Bank, No. SC-2025-0419 (Ala. Nov. 6, 2026) — Released opinion (PDF mirror of the Alabama Supreme Court release, “Rel: November 6, 2026”), read 2026-11-16. Opinion by Justice Sellers; Justices Mendheim, McCool, and Parker concur; Justice Bryan concurs in the result, with opinion, joined by Chief Justice Stewart; Justices Shaw, Wise, and Cook recused. Reversed and remanded with directions to enter judgment for the law firm. Interlocutory appeal from Jefferson Circuit Court, CV-24-902787.
  2. Justia opinion page, Maynard Nexsen, PC v. Cadence Bank (2026) — Secondary reprint used to cross-check the docket number and date.
  3. Ala. Code § 6-5-574(a) (as quoted in the opinion) — Two years after the act, omission, or failure; six-month extension from discovery if the claim could not reasonably have been discovered within two years; no action more than four years after the act, omission, or failure. Confirm the current official text before relying on it.
  4. Fox v. Hughston, 382 So. 3d 1207 (Ala. 2023) — Cited in the Maynard Nexsen opinion as describing the prior split between the “damage” and “occurrence” approaches. Not independently re-read for this draft.