Arkansas Supreme Court upholds law reviving childhood sexual-abuse civil claims
In short. On November 5, 2026, the Arkansas Supreme Court held, 3–2, that the General Assembly may revive civil claims that were already time-barred and upheld the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act against a constitutional challenge. In H.C. v. Nesmith, 2026 Ark. 177, the court reversed the dismissal of four survivors’ civil claims and remanded the case for further proceedings. The court did not decide whether the allegations are true. This is an informational summary, not legal advice.
Last reviewed:
On November 5, 2026, the Arkansas Supreme Court decided H.C. v. Nesmith, cited as 2026 Ark. 177, docket CV-23-328. The court held that Arkansas’s long-standing “vested rights” rule — which had treated an expired civil statute of limitations as a defense the legislature could not take away — has no basis in the Arkansas Constitution. It overruled that line of cases, upheld the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act against the defendant’s constitutional challenge, and reversed the dismissal of four people’s civil claims so the case can continue in the trial court.
The vote of the justices who participated was 3–2. Justice Nicholas J. Bronni wrote the majority opinion, joined by Special Justice Cory Cox. Justice Courtney Rae Hudson concurred in the result. Chief Justice Karen R. Baker and Justice Shawn A. Womack each filed a dissent. Justice Webb did not participate.
This summary is drawn from the court’s official opinion and from the compiled text of the statute the court applied. It is an estimate of what those sources say, not a calculation of any person’s deadline, and it is not legal advice. The court did not decide whether the underlying allegations are true.
The case, in brief
The appellants, identified in the opinion only by their initials — H.C., L.S., R.T., and T.K. — alleged that James Darrell Nesmith sexually abused them when they were children, at various times between 1995 and 2007. Three alleged that the abuse occurred during medical visits when Nesmith was a pediatric doctor. The fourth alleged abuse at Nesmith’s home and at a church camp where Nesmith was a counselor. Their complaint sought damages for sexual assault, sexual battery, and infliction of extreme emotional distress, including under Arkansas’s crime-victim civil statute, Ark. Code Ann. § 16-118-107.
The parties agreed that the plaintiffs had not sued within the generally applicable civil periods: three years for many torts under Ark. Code Ann. § 16-56-105, and, for minors, three years after turning twenty-one under § 16-56-116. They argued instead that the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act revived those already time-barred claims and that they had filed within the Act’s statutory window. The opinion states that this was undisputed, and that later amendments to the window were “not material” because everyone agreed the complaint was timely under the version then in effect. (The opinion’s footnote on those amendments cites “Act 117 of 2023.” The compiled code history lists 2023 Acts 177 and 616, and 2025 Act 662. This article flags that numbering difference and does not treat the footnote as a complete legislative history.)
Pulaski County Circuit Judge Timothy Davis Fox granted summary judgment for Nesmith and dismissed the complaint as untimely, applying the vested-rights precedent. The Arkansas Court of Appeals affirmed in H.C. v. Nesmith, 2025 Ark. App. 59, 705 S.W.3d 880. The Supreme Court granted review, reversed, remanded the case for further proceedings, and vacated the Court of Appeals opinion. The case number in the circuit court is 60CV-22-4435.
What the court held
The legal question, as the majority framed it, was whether the General Assembly may extend a limitations period after it has already run and thereby give child-sex-abuse survivors a chance to sue. Prior cases, including Hall v. Summit Contractors, Inc., 356 Ark. 609, 158 S.W.3d 185 (2004), and Johnson v. Lilly, 308 Ark. 201, 823 S.W.2d 883 (1992), had said no: once the period expired, the defendant had a “vested right” in that defense.
The majority concluded that this rule was not grounded in constitutional text. It described statutes of limitations as legislative policy judgments, not as property rights, and it “restore[d] to the General Assembly its constitutional power to decide how long is too long to bring a claim.” Because the Act was a valid exercise of that power, and because the plaintiffs had filed within the statutory window, the circuit court erred in dismissing the complaint on limitations grounds.
Justice Hudson agreed that the case should be reversed and remanded. She treated this as an “exceptional case” in which following the old rule would cause “great injury and injustice,” and she discussed why childhood sexual abuse is often reported late. She joined the holding that there is no categorical constitutional bar on legislative revival.
The dissents would have affirmed the dismissal. Chief Justice Baker would have adhered to what she described as nearly two centuries of precedent, beginning as early as Couch v. McKee, 6 Ark. 484 (1846), and would have held that the legislature lacked authority to include a revival window. Justice Womack likewise would have followed that precedent. He wrote that the allegations are deeply disturbing and that the policy behind the Act is compelling, but that once a limitations period has expired, Arkansas law has treated the defense as a vested right the legislature may not retroactively take away. He also emphasized the practical difficulty of defending very old claims. Those views did not command a majority.
The court did not decide the merits of the civil claims, did not impose liability, and did not change any criminal statute of limitations. This was a civil case about whether a lawsuit could proceed.
What the Act says, as compiled
The Act’s official session-law title is the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act, Act 1036 of 2021 (Senate Bill 676), approved April 29, 2021. The Supreme Court cited it as compiled at Ark. Code Ann. § 16-118-118 (Supp. 2025). (The 2021 session law originally drafted the section as § 16-118-117; it is now compiled at § 16-118-118.)
The statute has two parts that matter here, and they are easy to conflate. Some news headlines said the 2021 law “ended” or “eliminated” all time limits. The official texts are more specific.
Going-forward claims, subsection (b)(1). The original 2021 act allowed a “vulnerable victim” — a person who was a minor, a person with a disability, or both, at the time of the sexual abuse — to bring a civil action before reaching 55 years of age, against a person who committed the abuse or whose tortious conduct caused the person to be a victim. Act 616 of 2023 (Senate Bill 204), approved April 11, 2023, removed that age-55 limit. In the 2025 compiled text, (b)(1) provides that, notwithstanding any other statute of limitations, a vulnerable victim “may bring a civil action” of that kind. That compiled subsection does not itself state a filing deadline. News coverage and some secondary compilations describe this, after the 2023 amendment, as eliminating a civil time limit for qualifying claims going forward. Confirm the current official code.
Already-barred claims, subsection (b)(2). This is the provision the Supreme Court applied. It revives a similar civil action, including one that arose before, on, or after July 28, 2021, that “was barred or dismissed due to a statute of limitation,” and it allows that action to be commenced in a defined window. In the 2025 compiled text reproduced by Justia and consistent with the court’s citation to the 2025 supplement, the window is “not earlier than six (6) months after and not later than thirty (30) months after August 1, 2023.” Counted from that date, the window opens about February 1, 2024, and closes in early February 2026. The Act’s Senate sponsor and some secondary reports described a close of January 31, 2026. This article does not choose between those two end dates. It is dated November 12, 2026. That revival window appears to have closed. A lawyer licensed in Arkansas can confirm the official text and the exact last day.
The original 2021 revival window ran from six to 30 months after the 2021 act’s effective date (the compiled text uses July 28, 2021, as a reference date). Act 616 later amended the commencement language. The Nesmith plaintiffs filed in 2022 and, the court said, were timely under the window then in effect.
Subsection (c) says the section does not apply to a claim “litigated to finality on the merits” in a court of competent jurisdiction before July 28, 2021. Subsection (d) allows actual, compensatory, and punitive damages, injunctive relief, or other appropriate relief.
“Sexual abuse” is defined by reference to listed criminal offenses, including rape, sexual assault in the first and second degree, and certain offenses involving children. The 2025 compiled definition also lists capital rape. Qualifying defendants can include not only the person accused of the abuse but also a party “whose tortious conduct caused the vulnerable victim to be a victim of sexual abuse.”
What this may mean for survivors
This is the part that requires the most care, because a court decision about a law’s constitutionality is not the same thing as a promise that any particular person can still sue.
- The Supreme Court has now said that Arkansas’s Constitution does not bar the General Assembly from reviving civil claims after the old deadline has passed, and that this Act is valid against the challenge raised in Nesmith. Cases that were dismissed only because a court thought revival was unconstitutional may be able to go forward, as this one was. That is a case-specific question.
- People who already filed a qualifying civil claim during a statutory revival window, as the Nesmith plaintiffs did, are in a different position from people who have not yet filed. The court’s holding is directly about the first group.
- For claims that had already expired and were eligible only because of the (b)(2) revival window, that window appears to have closed in early 2026. This article does not say that a previously expired claim can still be filed today.
- For qualifying claims that were not already time-barred, the compiled (b)(1) text, after the 2023 amendment, does not state a filing deadline. How that text applies to a particular person — including how it interacts with already-expired claims after the revival window — is something this site cannot decide.
- Claims litigated to finality on the merits before July 28, 2021, are excluded by subsection (c).
- Deadlines, if any, can also depend on who is sued, the date of the alleged abuse, later amendments, and other law. Only a review of the facts and the current official code can sort that out.
If you are a survivor considering a claim, or if you already have a case pending, the practical step is to speak with a lawyer licensed in Arkansas as soon as you can. A conversation can address whether a claim is still timely, whether a case already filed may proceed, and what filing would involve. You do not have to recount every detail in order to ask for that help.
This subject can be painful to read about and painful to discuss. If you want confidential support that is not legal advice, RAINN operates a 24/7 national sexual-assault hotline at 800-656-HOPE (800-656-4673) and through online chat.
How to use this guide
This post is compiled by the Lawyer Dude® Team. It has not been independently reviewed by Joshua Wagner. It is not a complete statement of Arkansas law, and it is not a substitute for advice about a particular claim.
See also the compiled Arkansas statute of limitations table for the civil claim types this site already covers. Childhood sexual-abuse civil claims are a distinct statutory action under § 16-118-118; they are not the same as the general personal-injury cell on that table.
Confirm the current official opinion on the Arkansas Judiciary opinions site and the current official text of § 16-118-118 through the Arkansas General Assembly, and consult a lawyer licensed in Arkansas. Visiting this site does not create an attorney-client relationship, and it does not state that Joshua Wagner is licensed in Arkansas.
Frequently asked questions
Did the Arkansas Supreme Court say that childhood sexual-abuse lawsuits have no deadline at all?
The court held that the General Assembly may revive already time-barred civil claims and that the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act is valid against the constitutional challenge in this case. The current compiled text of Ark. Code Ann. § 16-118-118(b)(1) does not itself state a filing deadline for a qualifying civil action. A separate subsection, (b)(2), created a defined revival window for claims that had already been barred or dismissed because of a statute of limitations. Whether a particular person can still file, or can go forward with a case already filed, depends on the facts and on the current official text. That is a question for a lawyer licensed in Arkansas.
Does this decision mean the allegations against the defendant are true?
No. The court decided a statute-of-limitations and constitutional question. It reversed a dismissal and sent the case back for further proceedings. It did not decide whether the alleged abuse occurred.
Is this legal advice, and does Joshua Wagner practice in Arkansas?
No. This is an informational summary of a published court opinion and a compiled statute. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. It is not a statement that Joshua Wagner is licensed in Arkansas. Consult a lawyer licensed in Arkansas about a particular claim.
Citations
- H.C. v. Nesmith, 2026 Ark. 177 (Nov. 5, 2026) — Official opinion, docket CV-23-328, read 2026-11-12 from the Arkansas Judiciary opinions site. Reversed and remanded; Court of Appeals opinion vacated. Majority opinion by Justice Nicholas J. Bronni, joined by Special Justice Cory Cox; Justice Courtney Rae Hudson concurring; Chief Justice Karen R. Baker and Justice Shawn A. Womack dissenting; Justice Webb not participating.
- Ark. Code Ann. § 16-118-118 (Supp. 2025), Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act — Citation as given in the opinion (Supp. 2025). The 2025 compiled text reproduced by Justia, a secondary official-code reprint, was read 2026-11-12. Confirm the current official Arkansas Code before relying on any wording. History noted on that reprint: Acts 2021, No. 1036, § 1; 2023, No. 177, § 17; 2023, No. 616, § 1; 2025, No. 662, § 68.
- Act 1036 of 2021 (Senate Bill 676), Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act — Official session-law PDF, approved April 29, 2021. Originally proposed as Ark. Code § 16-118-117; later compiled at § 16-118-118. The original (b)(1) allowed a qualifying civil action before the plaintiff reached age 55. The original (b)(2) revived previously barred claims in a window of six to 30 months after the act’s effective date.
- Act 616 of 2023 (Senate Bill 204) — Official session-law PDF, approved April 11, 2023. Removed the age-55 limitation in (b)(1) and amended the commencement date for the revival window in (b)(2).
- Arkansas official code / legislature portal — Confirm the current official text of § 16-118-118 before relying on any period or window date.
- Brett Barrouquere, “Arkansas Supreme Court ends time limitations to sue in child sex abuse cases,” Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, Nov. 6, 2026 (updated Nov. 7, 2026) — News account used only as a starting point. Facts about the holding, the vote, and the statute in this article were checked against the official opinion and the compiled statute. Where the headline says the law “ends” or “eliminat[es]” all time limits, this article follows the statute’s own two-part structure, described below.
®